Completed Event: Volleyball versus Georgia Southern on October 25, 2025 , Win , 3, to, 2 , (27-25, 23-25, 25-13, 22-25, 15-10)
VB
Final

James Madison
3

vs Georgia Southern
(27-25, 23-25, 25-13, 22-25, 15-10)
2
| Season | Affil. | Record | Conference Reg. Season | Conference Tourn. | NCAA/AIAW | National Rank | Head Coach |
| 1973 * | AIAW | 8-1-2 | Leotus Morrison | ||||
| 1974 * | AIAW | 7-3-3 | Leotus Morrison | ||||
| 1975 * | 10-6-3 | AIAW Nat'l. Tourn. | Leotus Morrison | ||||
| 1976 * | AIAW | 8-5-4 | AIAW Region II Tourn. | Leotus Morrison | |||
| 1977 * | AIAW | 17-3-3 | 1st Blue Ridge District | 1st AIAW Region II; AIAW Nat'l. Tourn. | Leotus Morrison | ||
| 1978 * | AIAW | 13-6-0 | 5th VAIAW | Janet Luce | |||
| 1979 @ | AIAW I | 13-5-3 | 1st VAIAW | 4th AIAW Region II | Dee McDonough | ||
| 1980 @ | AIAW I | 13-15-1 | 4th VAIAW | 5th AIAW Region II | Dee McDonough | ||
| 1981 @ | AIAW I | 8-9-5 | 2nd VAIAW | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1982 # | NCAA I | 11-8-0 | 1st VIL | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1983 # | NCAA I | 13-9-1 | 2nd VIL | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1984 $ | NCAA I | 13-9-1 | 3rd SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1985 $ | NCAA I | 9-11-2 | 2nd SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1986 $ | NCAA I | 18-6-0 | 2nd SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1987 $ | NCAA I | 9-13-1 | 4th SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1988 $ | NCAA I | 11-12-1 | 2nd SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1989 $ | NCAA I | 9-11-1 | 3rd SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1990 $ | NCAA I | 7-16-1 | 4th SAC | Dee McDonough | |||
| 1991 ! | NCAA I | 11-7-1 | Tied 2nd | 1st round SAC | 13th | Christy Morgan | |
| 1992 ! | NCAA I | 6-13-0 | Tied 5th | Semis | Christy Morgan | ||
| 1993 ! | NCAA I | 18-6-0 | 2nd | 2nd | Quarterfinals | 8th | Christy Morgan |
| 1994 ! | NCAA I | 20-3-1 | 1st | 2nd | Champions | 3rd | Christy Morgan |
| 1995 ! | NCAA I | 19-5 | 1st | Champion | Semifinals | 3rd | Christy Morgan |
| 1996 ! | NCAA I | 13-9 | 3rd | 2nd | 16th | Christy Morgan | |
| 1997 ! | NCAA I | 17-7 | 2nd | 2nd | First Round | 7th | Christy Morgan |
| 1998 ! | NCAA I | 14-9 | 2nd | 2nd | 9th | Christy Morgan | |
| 1999 ! | NCAA I | 15-7 | 2nd | 2nd | First Round | 9th | Christy Morgan |
| 2000 ! | NCAA IÂ Â | 12-9 | 3rd | 2nd | 12th | Irene Horvat | |
| 2001 ! | NCAA I | 12-9 | 2nd | 2nd | 16th | Irene Horvat | |
| 2002 ! | NCAA I | 13-9 | Tied 3rd | Semis | First Round | 12th | Irene Horvat |
| 2003 ! | NCAA I | 6-14 | 5th | Irene Horvat | |||
| 2004 ! | NCAA I | 4-16 | Tied 6th | Antoinette Lucas | |||
| 2005 ! | NCAA I | 11-9 | Tied 3rd | 1st round | Antoinette Lucas | ||
| 2006 ! | NCAA I | 15-8 | 2nd | Champion | First Round | 13th | Antoinette Lucas |
| 2007 ! | NCAA I | 19-4 | 2nd | Champion | Quarterfinals | 7 | Antoinette Lucas |
| 2008 ! | NCAA I | 18-3 | 1st | Champion | First Round | 4 | Antoinette Lucas |
| 2009 ! | NCAA I | 12-8 | 3rd | Quarterfinals | 11 | Antoinette Lucas | |
| 2010 ! | NCAA I | 9-10 | 5th | Antoinette Lucas | |||
| 2011 ! | NCAA I | 9-10 | 4th | Quarterfinals | Antoinette Lucas | ||
| 2012 ! | NCAA I | 11-8 | 3rd | Quarterfinals | Antoinette Lucas | ||
| 2013 ! | NCAA I | 10-8 | t-3rd | Antoinette Lucas/ Michael Boal |
|||
| 2014 ! | NCAA I | 12-8 | 4th | 2nd | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2015 ! | NCAA I | 14-6 | 1st | 2nd | 18th | Christy Morgan | |
| 2016 ! | NCAA I | 13-7 | 3rd | Runner-Up | 17th | Christy Morgan | |
| 2017 ! | NCAA I | 12-5 | 2nd | Semis | 18th  | Christy Morgan | |
| 2018 ! | NCAA I | 6-12 | t-4th | Semis | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2019 ! | NCAA I | 8-11 | 4th | Semis | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2020-21 ! | NCAA I | 6-2 | 1st | Runner-Up | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2021 ! | NCAA I | 12-7 | 1st | Runner-Up | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2022 | NCAA I | 10-7 | N/A | N/A | 23rd | Christy Morgan | |
| 2023 | NCAA I | 5-12 | N/A | N/A | Christy Morgan | ||
| 2024 ^ | NCAA I | 14-6 | T-1st | Runner-Up | Christy Morgan |